Nice photo to acompany the article.
From the idea that the series rocked to the actors highlighted...nothing to disagree with here.

cheryl | June 27, 15:47 CET

Hands down to the all mighty that is Joss! BtVS will always be the best in my book. I'm glad to have seen it since the very first time :)

slayermuch | June 27, 18:08 CET

I was very happy to see this when I got my issue in the mail Friday. :-D

And, damn it, I was trying to post this earlier but couldn't find it anywhere on the EW site!

UnpluggedCrazy | June 27, 19:58 CET

I feel like a dork for half expecting to see Highlander on that list. But silly me, how could I forget about Topper.

Scotto | June 27, 19:59 CET

Although my own personal tastes would also put Highlander on the best list, I have to say, I loved Topper. I used to watch it in reruns as a kid and it was one of my favorite shows. I rmember being rather disappointed in the movie when I saw it years later.

The one thing I do not agree with in the Buffy love however, is that they did not go quite far enough. I think James Marsters should have been on the should have won an Emmy list. Otherwise, right there with them.

newcj | June 27, 20:54 CET

Wow. I just clicked on the All About Buffy link under the article and spent way too much time on a rather lovely Buffy nostalgia trip.

There are some great articles there. An especially enjoyable interview with Brendon. Marti Noxon actually saying that Ripper was delayed because of Firefly, and just a whole bunch of other stuff I never knew.

I have to say though that not including James Marsters on the "should have got an emmy list" is as big a faux pas to me as OMWF not getting an emmy nomination.

Xane | June 27, 22:02 CET

There was an Uncle Buck TV show? Wow I never knew and I love that movie (John Candy = one of my favourite on-screen performers).

Simon | June 27, 22:08 CET

EW missed a big one in the "worst" category: Casablanca. Not one, but TWO failed TV spinoffs, one in 1955 and the second in 1983 (starring a post-"Starsky & Hutch" David Soul).

cjl | June 28, 01:03 CET

Only the Core Four for Emmies? I don't think so!

Gill | June 28, 02:44 CET

The core four plus David Boreanaz, for his portrayal of Angelus alone, would have been my choices for emmy's.
Juliet was also amazing but if I could only vote for one....SMG. Hands down.

cheryl | June 28, 08:06 CET

Simon, I, too, was surprised by the Buck thing. I also love UB; my husband and I pull out lines from that movie at least once a week.

My big disagreement is with the comment about the original Parenthood being mediocre. I think that's a brilliant family movie, and I am NOT a supporter of Opie Cunningham's work. In fact, Parenthood is the only movie of his I think works at all.

mosie | June 28, 20:32 CET

I feel really out of the loop but I had no idea about Joss' connection to Parenthood. Never saw the movie or the show. Is there some kind of all-inclusive list somewhere of stuff Joss has done? Just curious.

Xane | June 28, 22:06 CET