"That's right! Just dial 1-800-CHOSEN-1 to meet girls who have this alarming yet fun condition."
July 19
2007
David Greenwalt on why 'Moonlight' is no 'Angel'.
For one, it doesn't have the word 'Angel' in its title.
Yorick
| AtS
| 04:28 CET
|
35 comments total
| tags: angel, moonlight, david greenwalt
You need to
log in to be able to post comments.
About
membership.
« Older
Amber Benson to star in Girltrash.
|
Allyson Beatrice interviewed by Se...
Newer »
© 2002 - 2008 - WHEDONesque.com
(
e-mail)
Individual posts are copyright their respective authors
This is a non-profit, unofficial website, not affiliated with Mutant Enemy, Inc., 20th Century Fox, Warner Brothers or UPN.
RaisedByMongrels | July 19, 04:52 CET
goth_huntress | July 19, 05:35 CET
[ edited by Jobo on 2007-07-19 06:03 ]
Jobo | July 19, 06:02 CET
Hmm, that really isn't encouraging me to watch the show.
The cancellation of Angel left me with a bitterness toward network television. So much so, that a series with a premise so close to a show I loved so much kind of feels like a slap in the face.
Yes, I'm aware that CBS isn't the network that cancelled Angel but it still feels that way. Unreasonable, yes...but I can't seem to view the similarities unemotionally.
I honestly wish Mr. Greenwalt and the cast and crew of this show all the best of luck but I don't think I'll be able to watch Moonlight.
menomegirl | July 19, 06:26 CET
Yorick | July 19, 07:11 CET
There is a lot of sci-fi and genre out this year. I plan on supporting as many as possible.
We all know that studios and networks hate to take risks, but they certainly love a popular bandwagon. If we want more Jossy goodness maybe we should encourage execs to think that genre is highly profitable.
TamaraC | July 19, 08:12 CET
gossi | July 19, 09:42 CET
Cool, he's very obviously not Angel in any way from a character perspective. He's Spike ;-).
Not sure about the daylight thing, if you take too many of the mythological aspects away then what makes them vampires ? That said, it doesn't sound like they're totally free to move around in the sun (just that they can without blankets. Or catching fire ;). Sounds a bit like a book I read a while back, 'Already Dead', which is a sort of vampire/hard-boiled detective story where vampirism is a virus borne disease and vamps can stand very small amounts of direct sunlight but more than a few minutes and they'd be dead from what are, effectively, extremely malignant and aggressive tumours (not bad, writing was a bit clunky in places but i'll be checking out any follow-ups).
(and i'll be giving 'Moonlight' a fair chance, partly just because it's a rare genre show that doesn't get that from me and partly because of DG's involvement)
Saje | July 19, 10:43 CET
So far, Moonlight doesn't sound very good to me, but I'm not gonna say more until I see it. Plus, it's got David G. on board.
UnpluggedCrazy | July 19, 11:23 CET
Valerie | July 19, 11:36 CET
Simon | July 19, 11:48 CET
True but obviously vampires were around in myth (and fiction) long before Stoker (you didn't even need a wooden stake to kill his vampires) and in modern tellings daylight aversion of varying degree has become part of the mythology.
It's a fair point though that vampire mythology is very varied so there's a lot of leeway in which traits are used (not many modern tellings have shapeshifting for instance and who even remembers the 'not able to cross running water' thing ?).
Saje | July 19, 12:12 CET
You go Saje. I will support the show too. For one it's got what's his name form Veronica Mars. Sorry it's early in the AM and my steel trap mind is rusted shut. But, yeah, this is the girl.
RazorBlade | July 19, 12:26 CET
Pumps | July 19, 14:23 CET
Teacherdarling | July 19, 14:24 CET
That pretty much sealed the deal with me. I was probably going to check out an episode or two anyway, but with JD on board it's going to be a nice little ride. ;)
Haikes | July 19, 14:42 CET
wissxwe | July 19, 14:44 CET
BUT vampire-, David Greenwalt- and Jason Dohringy-goodness will reel me in, I'm sure.
Fitz | July 19, 15:43 CET
AncientMagicks | July 19, 16:47 CET
biffsbabe | July 19, 16:57 CET
luvspike | July 19, 16:59 CET
*burns 'Angel' DVDs*
Saje | July 19, 17:07 CET
Craig Oxbrow | July 19, 17:15 CET
zeitgeist | July 19, 17:26 CET
I do actually. The sunlight kills part of the vampire mythos seems to have originated with Nosferatu, so it's a fairly late addition, and probably was borrowed from traditional folklore ideas of ghosts having to return to the grave before sunrise (e.g. the wonderful ballad "The Wife of Usher's Well", one of my favorites).
Joss got rid of the having to sleep in coffins bit, as well as being able to crawl up a vertical wall, like a fly, so there's definitely pick and choose going on. Wasn't there also something about having to have earth from a graveyard in the coffin in Stoker's Dracula?
barboo | July 19, 17:36 CET
Also, rewatched Kindred: The Embraced over the course of last week, and the shape-shifting was there, also the vamps could be out in sunlight briefly if they'd recently fed.
Willowy | July 19, 18:29 CET
Plus, I've got like a Queen and these emeralds and...yeah, my mythology could be zestier.
UnpluggedCrazy | July 19, 19:49 CET
I'm not too worried about vampires walking in the daytime. Practically every culture throughout history has a vampire myth and they are all different to some degree.
Being on CBS is an added bonus. At least it won't be canceled before the first commercial break has come and gone.
aeval | July 19, 20:27 CET
[ edited by barboo on 2007-07-19 21:17 ]
barboo | July 19, 21:15 CET
Also, in terms of vampire myth-tweaking, don't forget Joss invented the whole turning to dust upon death bit.
barboo | July 19, 21:16 CET
That's very true and hopefully, that'll be the case for 'Moonlight'. And I suppose you could say that 'Star Trek: Voyager' and 'Battlestar Galactica' followed in the footsteps of 'Lost In Space', which followed 'Star Trek' and so on and so on......
Ha! And after laughing insanely....
I can't speak for anyone except myself but no, not really. I was a fan of Forever Knight (didn't care for how that series ended, either) but I never once assiocated Angel with it, even when others did. Perhaps it's because Angel grew out of Buffy and I knew the characters from the beginning, I'm not sure. For me, I'd have to say it's the way the WB handled the cancellation and that Not Fade Away didn't give me a complete sense of closure the way Chosen did....or maybe I'm still just supremely pissed because Joss killed Lindsey...I don't know. *huffs*
I actually love the vampire genre in the main, hell I even liked parts of Btvs the movie but the second I read what Moonlight was about, it was like um....lost my Slayer cool, and saw only Angel, which automatically equaled maxi-wig?
There is that. I have to say, the rapid way shows get the axe nowadays is very disturbing to me and it makes me not want to try anything new.
menomegirl | July 19, 21:20 CET
By the way, that brings up another point. Hey TV advertisers, I'm not a mindless, slobbering drone who's waiting with baited breath to try your products, similar to the consumers your commercials portray. Treat me with intelligence if you're going to sell me something.
quantumac | July 19, 22:58 CET
Why couldn't CBS just make a deal that no one could refuse to bring back "Angel" instead? (Do we reeeeeally need 'Bones'?) ;)
harvey chin | July 20, 02:59 CET
I won't watch just anything that's genre (see: SciFi Channel) but I will support a quality production. We need more genre work in mainstream television. It can't be all lawyers and doctors.
Tonya J | July 20, 16:26 CET
(over here, 'Firefly' has only ever been broadcast on Sci-fi, so you sometimes get unexpected gems on there. Course, a lot of the time you get stuff like 'Painkiller Jane', life is risk ;)
Saje | July 21, 13:34 CET