This site will work and look better in a browser that supports web standards, but it is accessible to any browser or Internet device.

Whedonesque - a community weblog about Joss Whedon
"Ten percent of nuthin' is...let me do the math here...nuthin' into nuthin'...carry the nuthin'..."
11945 members | you are not logged in | 25 October 2014




Tweet







July 28 2007

Warren Ellis to write Astonishing X-Men. Joss and John's successors get announced. And an interview with the new artist Simone Bianchi can be found here.

So this is why Joss is out to get Ellis.

The plot thickens.
You know I had good money on it being BKV but bloody hell Ellis is such a good choice. I can't wait to see him write Emma Frost.
BKV has had a good run on X-Men already, and I doubt he'd sully himself by following Joss on a Marvel title. Everyone knows it's meant to go the other way round. ;)
I've seen some Ellis backlash on the internet recently, mostly because he's perceived to be kind of a dick. I don't really care, his work can be hit/miss, but he's capable of greatness.
I just came to post this. This is really exciting news. THough the tease/mystery image of Wolverine over on newsarama has him in his Ultimate uniform. Hope they're not related.
Ellis can be dickish, but 89.5% of the time he does it in excellently humorous fashion.
I was hoping Mike Carey would get Astonishing, since he certainly deserves it. I'm not sure about Ellis, especially after his run on Excalibur. I'm afraid what he'll do with Kitty (assuming Joss doesn't kill her).
Yeah Dirk. Besides, the whole cranky old man act that Ellis puts on is mostly just that. An act.

I can't wait to get my hands on his new novel.
Also, CBR has an interview with Alonso about Ellis/Bianchi on Astonishing:
http://www.comicbookresources.com/news/newsitem.cgi?id=11349
Wow, and here I was figuring I was just going to drop Astonishing once Joss finished with it.
Ellis is good.

But honestly, I really really really do not like Simone Bianchi.
On his run on Wolverine with Jeph Loeb, all the full-body shots were way off. He doesn't know his anatomy and I can see it.

Fat torsos, flat-drawings, bodies that twist wierd are yucky.

BKV and Cassaday would have been just riddichio!

*dreams of the amazingness that could've been*
Looks like they are hinting that X-23 will be joining the team. Be cool to see a new Wolverine teacher/student relationship building when Kitty, his original student, is on the team with them both. All you need is Jubilee to show up and class is in session. ;)

Question for the mods. Are we still going to be covering Astonishing X-Men when Ellis takes over? Technically it won't be a Whedon project anymore but he was the reason the book came to be in the first place. Are we nearing the end of X-related links at Whedonesque?
Whaaaaaa? Fantastic! I thought I'd be done with AXM after Joss was finished, but they chose one of the handful of writers that could make me stick with it.
I follow writers... Or in this case, I stay put as writers come on board, rather than following writers as they leave. :D

(Now... who else would like, say, a Giles story or a Spike and Dru story by Doktor Ellis?)
I'd like to see a Giles-as-Ripper story by Ellis...
A Hellblazer style Ripper story by Ellis or Garth Ennis would be cool, but I remember reading on Ellis' old site Die Puny Humans that he never really got into Buffy. Didn't dislike it, but he said he'd only ever seen Graduation Day.

[ edited by NekoDono on 2007-07-28 02:06 ]
I really enjoy Ellis non-mainstream super-hero work, but on the other hand, I'm close to despise his mainstream super-hero work.

Don't really know what I feel about this, I'm reading less and less marvel everyday, and I still have bitter memories from some of his work in certain x-books.
Ellis is going to rock on this. Anyone who wants to know what he's about, pick up "Fell." You'll be glad you did. Bianchi, on the other hand, is not my favorite. His style was ok for like one issue of Wolverine, but it's really hard to look at now. But Cassaday's art is so fantastic, no one could do nearly as good.
Personally, I could live with Alan Davis drawing for AXM... Haven't seen any Bianchi, but I will eventually, apparently.
Hmm, this could be absolutely brilliant, I just hope Ellis plays it straight and doesn't get bored and start deconstructing everything in sight.

And I was really excited when I heard about the artist but then realised I was thinking of Ariel Olivetti (who did some stunning work on 'Legends of the Dark Knight' just before it ended - kind of a slightly darker, more grounded Alex Ross). Only seen Bianchi's covers for Detective but those have been pretty good IMO so i'll wait and see what his panel's are like.
I think Warren Ellis is an honestly astonishing writer, and his progressive ideas could work great on a book like this... but I'm not so sure I like him on a flagship X-book.

The reason those themes that Ellis likes work so strongly in X-Men, is because they're package in soap opera. A core book like this really needs a writer with a love and respect for the characters and their history, and I just don't think Ellis has that.

Plus, apparently Astonishing will continue to separate itself from the other X-books as possible, and I hated that even when Joss did/does it.

So I'll certainly check the book out, but I'm keeping my fingers crossed.

Bianchi? Meh. He can do real pretty stuff, but then there's the Wolverine story he just finished...
Ellis is the perfect choice. I googled Bianchi's work and...I'm on the fence. It doesn't seem like he pays attention to proportions at all. I see potential though.

But thank god its Ellis.
Nnh. I was honestly hoping Marvel would end the series when Joss and John Cassiday were done.

I know that any subsequent creative group on this series will be unable to measure up to what J&J and crew have given us, so it's likely that I would stop reading the series anyway. As Ellis already has one series which he's taken over on the verge of being crossed off of my pull list, it looks like I'll be making a definite note to remove Astonishing from it.

You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.



joss speaks back home back home back home back home back home