Whedonesque : Comments on 14577 : Entertainment Weekly's Top TV Icons.

This site will work and look better in a browser that supports web standards, but it is accessible to any browser or Internet device.

October 29 2007

Entertainment Weekly's Top TV Icons. Buffy squares off against other legends in EW's Top TV Icons Bracket Game.

sunnydalegirl | BtVS | 19:31 CET | 13 comments total | tags:

That was fun, but there comes a point where I couldn't vote for Buffy as the most iconic: my very final two was between Jack Benny and Bob Newhart, who were both so brilliant in everything (I finally went w/Bob Newhart).

embers | October 29, 21:11 CET

It came down to Lucy and Sarah for me...love Lucy but Sarah is number one in my heart...fun exercise

Calledon | October 29, 21:23 CET

Oh, dear, how could they put her up against Samantha?!? I'm sorry, but Buffy didn't even make it out of the first round for me. My final battle was between Carol Burnett and Bill Cosby, with Bill Cosby eeking out the win.

cabri | October 29, 21:39 CET

Real fun. Some brought back many memories and it was hard at times. It's good to see faces from the past we still love.

Jademaliburoad | October 29, 22:23 CET

For me ... it came down to Buffy and Shatner. I'm such a geek. =)

SenseiJJ | October 29, 22:57 CET

She came up against Frasier in her round. I loves ya Buff, but Frasier is the one.

Final round: Frasier vs Michael J Fox. Don't make me choose. *sobs* Nope, can't do it. I can't choose between them. But I have to. Aaargh!!!

*deep breath*

Frasier it is. Sorry Michael. Carrie Bradshaw came third. Wonder Woman totally beat out Buffy too.

JuliaL | October 29, 22:58 CET

I never thought I'd see a Buffy vs. Hawkeye showdown.

Simon | October 29, 23:31 CET

Buffy defeated the entire first cast of Saturday Night Live!

Maeve | October 30, 00:51 CET

I agree with Cabri, SMG didn't make it past the first round for me! Buffy - as great as she is - isn't the legend that Samantha Stevens is. Not yet.

crossoverman | October 30, 02:39 CET

Buffy vs. Captain Kirk! I figured Buffy could take him as long as Spock wasn't around.

bojojoti | October 30, 03:14 CET

For me it was Buffy vs. Dick Van Dyke. As much as I love the Dick Van Dyke Show I had to go with the Buffster. I tended to skew toward comedians in general though. Letterman, Kovacs, Newhart, Lucy, Hartmann. Got down to some tough choices.

batmarlowe | October 30, 05:10 CET

Comedy and drama, old shows and recent, are hard to compare. It came down to Buffy and Andy Griffith for me. Kirk made it through one round. Picard would have lasted longer.

Sunfire | October 30, 16:32 CET

I gave Buffy a pass to round two, but in the end it came down to Dick Clark and Lucy. What can I say? I love Lucy!

WhoDied | October 30, 18:13 CET

You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.

« Older Fantasy travel with Princess Bride... | Happy Birthday Tim Minear! Newer »