Whedonesque : Comments on 14692 : Angel vs Mick St John.

This site will work and look better in a browser that supports web standards, but it is accessible to any browser or Internet device.

November 09 2007

Angel vs Mick St John. TV Squad pits Angel against Moonlight's Mick St John. Who wins?

JudyKay7 | AtS | 23:38 CET | 21 comments total | tags: angel, moonlight, mick st john

Well I voted for Angel.....obviously:)

And as of now Angel is kicking that pretenders ass 87.1% to 12.3% .And because its an internet poll its gotta be the truth..............

I mean really....nobody beats Angel:)

angeliclestat | November 09, 23:53 CET

I had to laugh when the offered the idea of a younger Angel taking on Mick. Come on- 50 years after being embraced, when Angel was still Angelus? He'd just beat up on Mick even worse. Angel at least would show mercy.

Another bonus to Angel- he doesn't sleep in a freezer.

Angel beats him in a rout.

kishi | November 10, 00:09 CET

Of course Angel would kick Mick's ass. So would Nick Knight and Henry Fitzroy. Although I'm pretty sure that LaCroix could beat them all.

goth_huntress | November 10, 00:09 CET

kishi when I initially scanned over your post I processed it as "Angel beats him in a trout".

I'm sure Angel could beat Mick with a trout, if he was feeling inventive. :D

Trek_Girl42 | November 10, 00:17 CET

HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA

Seriously? I couldn't sit through thirty seconds of that show. Its an embarrassment to vampires and science-fiction in general.

MySerenity | November 10, 00:17 CET

Angel would just look at the dude and Mick St. John would melt back into the steaming pile of mediocrity that he is.

UnpluggedCrazy | November 10, 00:38 CET

As long as the fight took place indoors or at night angel would crush Mick.

Mick is a detective. Angel is a champion.

ssick | November 10, 00:47 CET

Yeah. I'm afraid that until this St. John fellow has fought hordes of demons (not to mention Buffy Summers), killed his whole family, eaten half of Europe, and survived Cordelia Chase, Angel still has one up on him. Or, a few thousand up on him.

dispatch | November 10, 00:56 CET

Ahhh yes. Henry Fitzroy.
For a treat, oh boys and girls, read the Blood Books by Tanya Huff. Special fun for those of us who live in Toronto.

redfern | November 10, 01:09 CET

Personally I am really enjoying 'Moonlight', but yes: Angel would totally kick Mick's butt. Mick even admits that he is a delicate flower.

embers | November 10, 02:31 CET

Of course, being blonde, Beth could smack Angel up and down the street.

Craig Oxbrow | November 10, 03:47 CET

I'm afraid that until this St. John fellow has fought hordes of demons (not to mention Buffy Summers), killed his whole family, eaten half of Europe, and survived Cordelia Chase, Angel still has one up on him. Or, a few thousand up on him.

That has to be the funniest thing I've read all day.

menomegirl | November 10, 06:48 CET

Yes, Angel would definitely wipe the floor with Mick.

I've only seen one episode, last week's, but it seems to have some potential. Particularly given that it's a CBS show.

Irishrose | November 10, 08:20 CET

Angel would stomp Mick's butt.

Please.

Even in Bizarro World Angel would stomp his butt. Then Angel would taunt him by calling him a girl.

*laughing hysterically*

whedon is GOD | November 10, 10:16 CET

Of course Angel would kick Mick's butt. Especially verbally, considering the quality of writing for the two shows. Or, Angel could just sit and brood until Mick surrendered.

That being said .... not wanting to start a war here, but in the interest of accuracy and fairness ....

angeliclestat said:
"Nobody beats Angel."

Umm, did you happen to catch an AtS episode titled "Destiny"? ;)

Shey | November 10, 15:43 CET

LOL!!!!!

Fair enough. I meant more in a 'Angel-is-great-and-who-does-this-mick-think-he-is' kinda way rather than beat him in a fight (cos you could say the same re:Apocalypse Nowish:)).

But let this Angel fan have his moment:)

angeliclestat | November 10, 16:45 CET

All in good fun, angeliclestat. Definitely your moment :)

But damn, I have to admit I think Alex O'Loughlin is adorable. Heresy, I know.

Shey | November 10, 17:40 CET

Don't feel bad Shey, there's definite cuteness there. Unfortunately, shows can't survive on cuteness alone (though when add Jason Dohring to the equation, maybe...). Though I do hope Irishrose is right and things are starting to look up.

deepgirl187 | November 10, 19:13 CET

Excuse me... a vampire that can walk in the dessert with only sunglasses and a baseball cap also stakes don't kill (who writes this ^%$#)... can we say unfair advantage.

demon magnet | November 10, 20:19 CET

Yeah, but Angel's fought tons of things that can walk in the sun and that stakes don't kill, and still won. I don't think it's really any help to Mick at all. Sure, Mick has his abilities, but Angel is a born warrior. It wouldn't even take long.

IMForeman | November 11, 23:09 CET

Personally, I think a caveman would beat them both.....

ohbejoyful | November 13, 05:32 CET

You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.

« Older Being an extra on the set of Danny... | (SPOILER) Solicitation for Buffy #11. Newer »