This site will work and look better in a browser that supports web standards, but it is accessible to any browser or Internet device.

Whedonesque - a community weblog about Joss Whedon
"Yeah, people are mostly crap."
11981 members | you are not logged in | 25 April 2018


June 10 2003

Review of the Season 4 (region 1) DVD which is released today. So was it a case of a season full of great episodes but a poor plot arc?

There's a fairly negative review of Season 4 here.

I liked season 4, it was a transitional period with a hell of a lot going on (I even liked Riley). The Faith storyline and the Willow/Oz breakup was terrific viewing but the Initiative plot arc went nowhere, though I understand that it got changed due to the sudden departure of Lindsay Crouse who played Maggie Walsh. Apparently she was going to be the major big bad but instead that fell to Adam. But that may just be rumours.

But whatever is said and done, 'Hush' is one of the best Buffy episodes ever and 'Restless' my favourite Buffy season finale.

I can't wait for Hastings to open this a.m.! Got mine reserved & I'm looking forward to a very Buffy evening. Simon, yes, 'Hush' is one of the best episodes ever, of ANY television program, but being a BtVS fan, I'm sure I am a tad biased. :D
I've had the DVD since Thursday - God bless the illicit DVD retailers of Greenwich Village!

As a recently-ordained fan, I've enjoyed Season 4 more than any other. It edges out 3 for me because of the masterful Oz-Willow-Tara love triangle, the very realistic heartbreak over Parker (by Buffy) and Oz (by Willow), the increased use of Spike, and, to my surprise, Riley. I never much cared for Angel-Buffy, so I'm finding myself more involved than ever with these plots. Thus far I've seen up to "The I in Team" ... maybe it gets worse from here. But watching Spike beg Willow and Xander to fight evil was mythical: "Come on, vampires! Raagh! Let's fight that evil!"

It's worth owning the DVD, of course. As Virginia Postrel says, the lack of commercials and cliffhangers (just click the remote and you're on the next episode) do wonders to enrich the series. "Hush," for example, is even better when there are no blaring old Navy ads in between silent horrors. When Buffy finally screams, after 30 minutes of watching these characters just react to the Gentlemen, tears just shot out of my eyes. I didn't cry - it was more like a sudden emotional sucker punch. That happens a lot in this set.

The features are good, too. Seth Green comments on "Wild at Heart," and he sits down for a fluffy Oz featurette. The music documentary, which nails down Chris Beck and Nerf Herder, is actually very informative.

My one qualm thus far: It gets old listening to the theme rom "Hush" every time you open a menu. But that's one qualm.
Wasn't Lindsey Crouse in the next-to-last episode, as one of Adam's zombies?
I went at lunch from work to HMV for my DVD. All this so I could get optimum watching time tonight. This day rocks
I got mine on Saturday. Thank god for e-tailers! I really enjoyed Season 4 up until the last 1/4 (save of course for the lyrical and brilliant "Restless") which I feel completely fell apart. I had always wished that Maggie had been the ultimate Big Bad instead of Adam who was in my opinion dull and rather boring. Maggie was a far more compelling and interesting character to explore. The ultimate showdown between technology and magic would have been better if it was Maggie in the final few episodes they were trying to stop and Adam was just cog in the greater plan (world domination anyone?) while Maggie goes over the edge, envisioning herself perhaps as a mother-Eve to her creation.

It's those last couple of episodes focusing on Adam that detract from the overall scope of the season...
The S4 DVD released on my birthday. How sweet it is!!
Just wanna say: I'm not a big fan of Season 4. I didn't enjoy a lot of the Season's humor at the expense of Xander, Giles and yeah, even Spike. Thought Adam was lame. Thought Maggie as mother-figure-gone bad was never quite defined properly. Constantly prayed for a sudden world conflict that would ship the Initiative out of Sunnydale.

Nevertheless, Buffy's final confrontation with Adam remains one of my favorite moments from the series. When the bullets burst into doves everything just clicks for me; and yeah, Hush and Restless are pretty damn near perfect.
I've always been a big fan of season 4, I like it just as much as 2 or 3 (I appreciate a LOT of people didn't like s4, but wouldn't it be boring if everyone had the same opinion). Now I just need to work out whether the extra features and the 4:3 framing makes it suffiently different to the region 2 dvd to buy it again... hmmm... :)
Happy Birthday voodoo-daddy! :D
The Joss-Marti-Seth commentary for "Wild at Heart" is hilarious. It gives you an idea of what it must have been like to be around the ME office back in the days when they didn't all hate each other.

This thread has been closed for new comments.

You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.

joss speaks back home back home back home back home back home