May 16 2008
"You're killing me! You're better than this".
Joss on how he intervened to save Eliza's career.
You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.
This site will work and look better in a browser that supports web standards, but it is accessible to any browser or Internet device.

That's our Joss.
jcs | May 16, 22:21 CET
Wyndam-Pryce | May 16, 22:21 CET
Would be nice to see Alexis working again... the last thing he did was HIMYM, right?? Like... 2 years ago...
...
But I totaly agree with Joss. Eliza is WAY better then the movies she was in...
maxsummers | May 16, 22:29 CET
Here we see Possibly Wry Joss after the Buffy panel at Paley(?). The tie is nice. Sarah Michelle Gellar's hair may be making a cameo on the left.
Sunfire | May 16, 22:51 CET
:)
MadeToLoveJoss | May 16, 22:57 CET
I love it. :)
SaltyGoodness | May 16, 22:58 CET
jnr616 | May 16, 23:00 CET
Edited for wrongitude.
[ edited by QuoterGal on 2008-05-16 23:37 ]
QuoterGal | May 16, 23:11 CET
"She's had some bad breaks. She goes with the independent, interesting young filmmakers and then they get slammed, like Southland Tales. I'm proud of what she's trying to do. It's hard."
I completely agree (for whatever that's worth.) I think SMG has made some brave choices that simply didn't work out or had mixed results like "Southland". But that doesn't mean she shouldn't be applauded for taking the lesser traveled road ("Scooby Doo" notwithstanding.) Personally I'd love to see Sarah get back into TV, maybe in something on FX or Showtime or HBO.
As to Joss' comments on Eliza, I didn't think "Wrong Turn" was all *that* bad, to be honest, and I'm kind of curious to see how "The Alphabet Killer" turns out from the same team. "Soul Survivors," yes, dreck.
Romo Lampkin | May 16, 23:13 CET
I totally understand how Joss feels. My heart breaks all the time after discovering the movies that Joss' alumni end up in. :(
Like Michelle Trachtenberg being in EuroTrip and Black Christmas.
Emma Caulfield in Darkness Falls.
Alyson Hannigan in the American Pie movies and Date Movie.
Julie Benz in Saw V and George of the Jungle 2.
Marc Blucas in Thr3e.
Charisma Carpenter in See Jane Date.
Mercedes McNab appearing in Playboy.
Nathan Fillion in White Noise 2.
And Summer Glau in Mammoth.
But hey, at least they're in something... and they end up making these movies a little less bad then the movies would have been without them. :)
xerox | May 16, 23:20 CET
swanjun | May 16, 23:26 CET
[ edited by TamaraC on 2008-05-17 00:01 ]
TamaraC | May 16, 23:32 CET
; >
*waves back*
[ edited by QuoterGal on 2008-05-17 02:13 ]
QuoterGal | May 16, 23:35 CET
FaithsTruCalling | May 16, 23:50 CET
I appreciate it's because of the RSS feed, but the full stop outside the quotation marks is killing me a little inside. Sorry to be that person.
MattK | May 17, 00:02 CET
I would love to see Amber Benson get regular work worthy of her rather than all this flitting about she does. C'Mon Joss, hire her, too!
Dana5140 | May 17, 00:20 CET
I see Joss as a starmaker, really. Not too many people knew about Chiwetel Ejiofor before "Serenity". Summer Glau and Nathan Fillion are poised for stardom, especially if his "Castle" pilot gets picked up by ABC next year. And...let's not forget Joss gave us the gift that is David Boreanaz.
impalergeneral | May 17, 00:21 CET
zeitgeist | May 17, 00:22 CET
bobster | May 17, 00:26 CET
evilmaharaja | May 17, 00:46 CET
I think the main reason why some actors are in "dreck" that is beneath them is the simple fact that no one is hiring them for anything else and they have to pay rent and just keep working. I really don't think Eliza was turning down quality parts in order to be in bad horror movies. Same thing goes for other Whedonverse actors.
TamaraC | May 17, 01:01 CET
cabri | May 17, 01:01 CET
I'm not sure Joss can claim Chiwetel Ejiofor, though. I think "Dirty Pretty Things" lit that star.
KnitWit | May 17, 01:03 CET
Djungelurban | May 17, 01:08 CET
He's referred to as "the great Chewitel Ejiofor" in the current New Yorker. He's already approaching iconic status.
Chris inVirginia | May 17, 01:08 CET
Mercedes McNab appearing in Playboy.
so, xerox, you're OK with Charisma's Playboy appearance? :)
stuart | May 17, 01:10 CET
Still, I don't think we should be too hasty in judging the career decisions that the Whedonverse actors have made- post series.
With so much competition for roles, you'd have to be one of the top 25 actors in the world to be able to pick and choose scripts.
We all gotta eat. (Though, this COULD explain why a lot of female actors with good roles are so darn skinny.)
missb | May 17, 01:32 CET
I seem to remember Eliza being pretty big news around my high school when Bring It On came out; I think that Tru Calling was just an unlucky break.
As for SMG, I think that her appreciation of the different and perhaps more thoughtful has hurt her in maybe the short run, but she is still respected. As for Scooby Doo, I've heard that the original script was supposed to be a lot more snarky and geared toward an older audience, but that they totally changed it.
Simply Irresistable was a great premise; the writers just didn't follow through. Cruel Intentions is one of my favorite roles of hers...ever. I loved The Return because it made me think. 'Twas different and good. I still need to see her newer movies (stupid injuries make it impossible to sit in a theatre and support my actors!). I love it when I hear her voice in things like Robot Chicken or Small Soldiers. Makes me smile.
I think that the problem for the Buffyverse actors at least is that some people might try and pigeonhole them in the "teen flick" horror or comedy if they do not understand the show. OTOH, SMG is a fantastic horror actress, and gives anything she's in more depth and scope.
The Serenifly actors have a slight pigeonhole into the SciFi genre. It happens with movies/shows.
Mattk, it is actually gramatically correct to put the period (or full stop, as you call it) either inside or outside the quotation marks, provided it is used properly. The reason that people do it inside the marks all the time is because that way you can't make a mistake. It's like why people don't use the word "whom".
ps...I watched A Knight's Tale last night; I had totally forgotten that Alan Tudyk was in it. That was fun.
BandofBuggered | May 17, 01:34 CET
And don't hate on "Euro-Trip"! That movie was *hysterical*.
Didn't "Four Brothers" come out before "Serenity"? People love Chiwetel in that. And he was in "Inside Man" -- was that before the Big Damn Movie? He was well on his way to stardom regardless.
KingofCretins | May 17, 01:39 CET
Glad he's looking forward to showing the world what she can do. Eliza is particularly soulful. Ooh: theme!
Pointy | May 17, 01:41 CET
witchlover | May 17, 02:00 CET
She's really quite a talented actress. Hell, all the cast were talented, tremendously so. I wish them all nothing but great roles in great shows and movies.
Chris inVirginia | May 17, 02:15 CET
Pointy, I'm going to stick with Big Purple Dude/His Purpleness. Mostly because I can't spell/pronounce "Auteur". (I copied that from your comment.)
Tru Calling wasn't THAT bad. Season 2 really added the meat to the series. I think she has too much range for something procedural; Dollhouse is a great fit for her.
Did anyone else notice that all of Joss' closies' names start with an "A"? Amy Acker, Alyson Hannigan, Alexis Denisof.
Speaking of Alexis... I heard from a convention interview with James Marsters that he often see Alexis at auditions. They audition for the same role all the time. Which means that Alexis keeps losing to James. Curse that Spike for stealing all of the lime light!
(Just joking. Love Spike. Love Wes. Group hug.)
korkster | May 17, 02:28 CET
These films were shot right after she ended Buffy and can hardly count for 50% of her post-Buffy career. You know what, people are hard on The Grudge but it worked out quite well for her. She got to go halfway around the world to film in Tokyo for 3 months, she made bank for Sony (and believe it or not money talks in this industry), and she propelled her status and exposure. She gave reasons why she took the film, it seemed interesting and she got to immerse herself in a completely different culture and take three months off to do a movie she really wanted to do. I don't see anything wrong with that at all. She may not have been Buffy but she was the lead in this movie and did not play just the wife or girlfriend, which is something she doesn't aspire to. If you think that's "undoing all Buffy's female-empowerment" status then I'm going to have to strongly disagree.
The second Grudge she did as a favour to the director who gave her a wonderful opportunity and she was hardly in it for five minutes.
As for The Return (in which her hair was a very dark brunette btw), it wasn't a horror flick and wasn't intended to be. If anything, it was a thriller that had a lot more to do with spirituality and reincarnation. She didn't exactly play the wife or girlfriend in that either. Personally, I think the movie fell flat but it was an interesting foray.
All her other choices, Southland Tales, The Air I Breathe, Suburban Girl, have been vastly different from these roles. I doubt she's trying to go for roles that are exactly like Buffy. You can't really compare a TV role to a few movie roles where characters aren't as well-developed, it's impossible. I say this for any TV show versus a movie. If you want her to be Buffy, then watch Buffy. If you're looking for Buffy, try looking elsewhere...like TV because that's probably the only place you'll find female characters that well-developed.
Joss himself sees what she's trying to do, it's not her fault if someone doesn't understand.
As for the comments about career interventions. I think as it stands, she's one of the few who doesn't actually need a "career intervention." She's not doing as well as perhaps...Chiwetel Ejiofor (who I recently saw in Red Belt, which the majority of my movie class were soso on/didn't like, we all agreed that he was great though) but she's doing okay. Nathan Fillion is also doing well for himself. I'm happy that at least some of the actors and actresses are still getting decent projects sent their way.
Here's a good line from some famous dude (paraphrased, of course), "If I waited on a good script to come along, I'd make a movie every five years." Al Pacino echoed this very sentiment to someone after starring in the absolutely horribly-review flop, 88 Minutes.
[ edited by Kyotoyoshi on 2008-05-17 03:48 ]
Kyotoyoshi | May 17, 03:12 CET
witchlover | May 17, 03:12 CET
When I travelled through Europe in my 20s, I had to go broke each time to do so. Michelle would have been crazy not to take the part.
-
Hjermsted | May 17, 03:21 CET
ManEnoughToAdmitIt | May 17, 03:31 CET
stuart - I totally forgot that Charisma appeared in Playboy. Its not like I have a subscription though. I find stuff out like that on wikipedia.
Joss' alumni, which I will now refer to as "The Company", are usually successful in the TV world but when it comes to movies...
But like I said, "The Company" takes the bad movies that their in and makes them enjoyable enough to watch.
I just watched Darkness Falls last night... If it hadn't been for Emma, three minutes into the movie I'd probably have been bored silly. But since she was in the movie I continued to watch. Every time she appeared on screen I said a loud, "She's So Cute!" and I was watching it by myself. She also did a really good job with the acting in all. ;)
xerox | May 17, 05:06 CET
And boy, that gal sure can cry.
QuoterGal | May 17, 05:31 CET
maxsummers | May 17, 05:33 CET
magnus carnage | May 17, 05:50 CET
Ally's biggest mistake was 'Date Movie' which was horrible, but American Pie was and still is a classic, it's what started that whole genre IMO and she already was in some of those movies whilst still being on Btvs anyway. And now she's on HIMYM which is doing pretty well yes?
DB is a star in 'Bones' and SMG has made some brave choices.
vampmogs | May 17, 06:15 CET
The Dark Shape | May 17, 06:23 CET
And yeah, Hannigan was getting set on fire and peed on in Dead Man on Campus (Mark Paul Gosselar--Zack from Saved By The Bell--Tom Everett Scott--American Werewolf in Paris/That Thing You Do, Lochlyn Munroe) while BtVS was still going on, so it's not like her career suddenly took a turn for the absurd after the show ended. I can't speak to the quality of How I Met Your Mother, haven't seen a second of it (aside from the whole Robin Sparkles/Canadian `90s pop sensation clip, to understand what all the LOL-ing was about on various sites), but apparently it's pretty decent as far as sitcoms go (does it have a laugh track?)...it's hard to make me happy for the past few years sitcom-wise though, after Scrubs and The Office and Flight Of The Concords kinda just reinvented (or at least reinvigorated) half-hour comedies...
Re: Way Off Broadway, I meant to watch that one for Morena too (okay, and for the dude in it who's seriously model-hot but also buff...Forbes March? Or is it Matt Davis? Can't remember). Like how I meant to watch Living 'til the End for Sean Maher and Slither for Nathan and...there might be other apparently worthwhile films featuring 'verse actors. So many movies and TV shows yet to watch (at least the list can be effectively narrowed with TV though).
Kris | May 17, 06:29 CET
TamaraC | May 17, 06:35 CET
I've enjoyed most of SMG's movies - but was a bit mystified at Suburban Girl, which I just finished watching 10 minutes ago. Who was the target audience? It flaunted some literary inside knowledge and, at times, a more indie feel in its framing, suggesting a hipper crowd, but also featured some incredibly bland dialogue, an excess of tedious musical interludes, and no obvious arc or direction. I felt we were never given a reason to care about Brett (SMG's character) or any of her relationships. I'm almost tempted to read the source book just so I can work out where on earth the adaptation was coming from.
I also just finished the first season of How I Met . . . on DVD. Really pretty funny, despite the laugh track. (The problem for me is not the track itself, but that the audience seems to be laughing in the wrong places, i.e. not at the bits I think are brilliant). For me it's the ensemble that makes the show, plus some fun play with story structure a la Coupling (I think the writers might even have watched a little Spaced too . . . ). NPH is very good but, I beg to differ, AH is absolutely terrific - and Josh Radnor does a tremendous, I think underrated, job in the thankless role of the straight man at the center of it all. Definitely recommend the show.
SoddingNancyTribe | May 17, 07:21 CET
Love that article! Thanks for posting. :)
Braeden Fireheart | May 17, 07:23 CET
Kris - The gross out sex comedy in general deserves getting bashed for all its worth because its gross and not creative... but thats my opinion. ;)
xerox | May 17, 07:25 CET
Plus, from what I've heard--blame wikipedia if I'm wrong--she was originally offered Tara Reid's role, but took the "Band Camp" girl's role because she thought it was funny. Which is pretty cool, because she could have done the whole teen princess sexy high school girl role.
And yes, that was definitely during BtVS. Didn't that lead to her's getting the "and" slot on the credits once ASH became special guest star dude?
I'm with SNT on Bring It On; I love that movie. 'Tis a guilty pleasure, as is I Know What You Did Last Summer, for both SMG and Jennifer Love Hewitt. Not to mention Mr. Prinze.
As for all of the Company belonging in Oscar-caliber roles (which I totally agree with), I think that their taking the cheesy teen/horror/not great movie roles they have is fine, as they're not as established as some of the known A-listers. Dues must always be paid. Someone like Christopher Walken whoring himself out to movies like Balls of Fury is inexcusable.
Despite all of the aforementioned roles that we've lamented, they still have more integrity...and a much longer, more illustrious future ahead of them.
BandofBuggered | May 17, 07:29 CET
Bring It On is the best movie about cheerleading ever, but that's not saying much... but its a really good movie in general. Plus we get see more then one member of "The Company". Clare Kramer and Eliza Dushku! :)
xerox | May 17, 09:28 CET
Best of luck to Joss, Eliza and everyone else connected with Dollhouse.
debw | May 17, 11:13 CET
I appreciated the heading too Simon
alexa | May 17, 11:37 CET
Kyotoyoshi, thanks for the sympathetic response to SMG's movie roles. I think she's doing OK in making a difficult transition from long-run Buffy character development to quick-shot genre roles ("Grudge") and ensemble cast performances ("Southland Tales"). Maybe her best or at least most vigorous role was in "Harvard Man."
As for Eliza, "Wrong Turn" really wasn't bad -- and everybody's right about the guilty pleasure of "Bring it On."
doghouse | May 17, 20:34 CET
I agree, starting to get a little worried about Alex. Has anyone heard a peep from him?
Madhatter | May 17, 20:54 CET
Dand5140:I know this is an old subject ebtween us, but I think Amber enjoys flitting around. AMybe she's aprt Took.
jnr616 korkster kyotoyoshi witchlover: Contmepalting SMG's career, ir ealize evry minute I don't work on my screenpaly is a crime against the cinema. Her co-starrign with Will Smitha s detectives would so endear the public to her. (Which wrietrs' agency works closest with Delusion Studios?) And the scene of ehr and Amber in the transluccent footless catsutis won't hurt.
DaddyCatALSO | May 17, 21:33 CET
UnpluggedCrazy | May 18, 02:37 CET
zeitgeist | May 18, 02:55 CET
Kris | May 18, 06:11 CET
OneTeV | May 18, 12:43 CET
Of all her films post-Buffy, and keeping in mind there's three I haven't seen yet, this one I like the most. She at least has an intriguing character that made me want to keep watching. I keep waiting for the release of The Air I Breathe but realize I need to search it and others on DVD.
Tonya J | May 18, 16:36 CET
cabri | May 18, 18:46 CET
DaddyCatALSO | May 19, 17:40 CET
Kyotoyoshi & witchlover, "The Grudge", "Grudge 2", & "The Return" are the movies I have seen of her recently. I was dragged to watch these movies, but hoped that SMG would give me something to enjoy besides the random and morbid deaths that would eventually follow. I will give her creds, that she was better than someone else to play the main character, but I still cringe that she was in it.
In those movies, an innocent still died in a not too clear way to leave some room for 1) a sequel or 2) your own ideas. And, like Joss, I'm tired of those movies. It just pains me to see the actors I've grown close to in them.
No, I have not seen "Southland Tales", "The Air I Breathe", or "Suburban Girl".
I saw the trailer for "Southland Tales", and the vibe I got was that she was playing a diva star (similar to Brittany Spears or Paris Hilton) who just got her own show that would tie her into the rest of the characters. That, plus bad reviews, turned me away from it.
It was the same for "The Air I Breathe". I know she was supposed to reflect an emotion (sorrow?) but with the same image I saw in ST, I still wasn't interested. And since it wasn't a horror film, I wasn't dragged to it.
Haven't heard about "Suburban Girl".
And, yes, I do place fault with her for making these choices. It's my opinion, that is all. Enjoying Japanese culture for 3 months was probably a great experience, but as far as the movie goes, it could have been better. And she could have gone to Japan on her own time.
I'm sure the flaying will commence now.
korkster | May 19, 23:34 CET
I think Suburban Girl is a rom-com. She plays opposite Alec Baldwin who's (cringe) only a year or two younger than I'm.
I wish Lucas and Spielberg would cast her in a remake of SHE! though.
At least she's not (inside joke most everyone here's too young to follow) doing a remake of Johnny LaRue's Polynesiantown.
DaddyCatALSO | May 20, 17:49 CET
Wow, good eye!
zeitgeist | May 20, 18:03 CET