What kind of a world puts Dr. Horrible against The Joker? That's just not right. :(

deepgirl187 | November 05, 23:34 CET

I know, it's messed up. Maybe it's part of the ELoE application process. They're testing his worthiness? I mean it is seriously evil.

DaisyButtercup | November 05, 23:41 CET

That was a truly heart-wrenching experience. For me, it came down to Dr. Horrible and The Office, and I sat there staring fretfully at it for two minutes before simply abandoning the attempt to choose one.

Taaroko | November 05, 23:46 CET

I (very, extremely begrudgingly) chose Neil over Heath. It has since left a sour taste in my mouth, because such choices just shouldn't have to be made.

deepgirl187 | November 05, 23:58 CET

Too bad he's in such an impossible match-up. Seriously, they've got my two top choices facing off in the first round. Curse you, EW!

kishi | November 06, 00:03 CET

Chose Neil over Heath. I have a whole new appreciation for the movie, Sophie's Choice. I gave up after making that painful choice...

I don't wanna play anymore EW :(

Emmie | November 06, 01:57 CET

If we're being honest and answering the "Who left the biggest mark on Pop Culture?" Then it has to be The Joker, hands down.

escapist_dream | November 06, 02:08 CET

Ridiculous choice, I agree! Joker v Dr Horrible? What is that? Clearly it should be a Joker and Dr Horrible team v the Twilight Conglomerate, once and for all destroying the Lamest Vampires Ever.

franklywarped | November 06, 02:38 CET

I'm with everyone else: NPH vs. Ledger? What? It pissed me off, but I had to vote Ledger.

Had it been Joss, however...

UnpluggedCrazy | November 06, 03:35 CET

My final two ended up being Tina Fey vs. the 2008 Presidential Race. Hm.

daedreams | November 06, 05:11 CET

I reluctantly had to vote Neil out in the very first round. I was a little bit heartbroken, but I can't go against the Joker in good conscious.

Then in the first half's final I had Tina Fey against the Joker, that one was a tough choice but i sided with Tina. The ultimate final was Tina Fey vs Jon Stewart/Stephen Colbert.

It's sad that it was easily the toughest decision I've made...today. Had to side with Tina Fey in the end though, you can't go past 30 Rock. I just want to apologize to everyone else on this list who epitomizes awesome but I had to leave out.

Nalliac | November 06, 05:49 CET

I was down to Stewart/Colbert and Dr. Horrible. I had to think about it awhile. As much as I love the 'fake' news it came down to this question: had I ever woke up the next morning singing anything from either of their shows?

chae | November 06, 07:11 CET

I too was paralyzed by indecisiveness when confronted with having to make a choice between The Joker and Dr Horrible. I ended up just closing my eyes, banging my mouse down on the desk and randomly clicking to get it over with. (The Joker won!)

missb | November 06, 07:28 CET

Joker wins against Dr H (sorry Dr H, your evil is insufficiently entertaining ;).

Choosing between Tina Fey and The Joker was tough.

Saje | November 06, 11:14 CET

Neil won for me. There was very little else I care the slightest bit about in that whole thing!

RachVG | November 06, 20:48 CET