This site will work and look better in a browser that supports web standards, but it is accessible to any browser or Internet device.

Whedonesque - a community weblog about Joss Whedon
"You forced me to come to Arizona. I loathe Arizona."
11980 members | you are not logged in | 23 October 2018


April 25 2009

TV Guide's Matt Roush: No worries on Castle. Also on page 4, Matt writes about being at the Whedon family reunion at Paley Fest.

Matt Roush: No worries on Castle. Itís not exactly a breakout hit, but it will do, and ABC needs a repeatable, reliable show like this in its stable. And with a little nurturing, it could become an even better show. (Without question, Nathan Fillion is a TV star.)

Makes me feel even better about the paper letter I just sent ABC thanking them for producing Castle.

Well, I have to agree about NF as a TV star, and I think his characterization of Castle as a reliable show, if not a breakout hit, is dead on.

After reading the section on the Dr. Horrible panel, though, and seeing that he got to meet the elder Whedon, I just wondered about the latter's response to Bea Arthur's death yesterday, after his having worked on Golden Girls. That surely is as big a blow as Andy Hallett's must have been for Joss.
Since Bea Arthur's death happened yesterday, it will take a while for TV Guide and Entertainment Weekly to have a proper column on her life. Remember, she's more than a Golden Girl. She's the first person who knocked Archie Bunker off his chair. That led to the classic spinoff a few months later. It's too bad TV Land hasn't announced a marathon for "Maude" but thats a good idea. Expect a lot tomorrow.

As for Castle, I gave up on the first episode when he got arrested, and his TV mom explained to the cops it's not his fault because he had no father figure. I also thought it would be Moonlighting all over again. After a few weeks, I may try again.
I am thoroughly enjoying Castle and will breathe a sigh of relief only when ABC officially announces Season 2.
ABC got put on my "Never Again" list after they canceled Pushing Daisies. I begrudgingly gave them another chance with Life On Mars.
Now, I'm giving them yet another chance with Castle.
Castle is one of only two shows currently on that I like enough to be worth the inconvenience of watching live.
Go Nathan!
Remember, she's more than a Golden Girl. She's the first person who knocked Archie Bunker off his chair.

Yes, she was fantastic, and such a breath of fresh air when she first appeared on All in the Family. I followed her to Maude, and she was such an alternative model of what a woman could be--both in RL and on TV. I didn't watch Golden Girls very often, but that show was also groundbreaking. Wonderful legacy.

I like Castle, although it isn't must see TV for me. Part of this has to do with Monday nights, which are busy ones for me, so I cannot sit down and concentrate on what is going on. But I hope it goes on to another season.
I can't believe Joss' Dad (Tom Whedon) wrote for The Electric Company!!!! I had no idea. You see, that is where my screen name comes from. Ever since I was a little girl, my dad has called me Jennifer of the Jungle. How funny! I wonder if He wrote any of the Jennifer of the Jungle pieces? If he did, Joss, tell your dad I said thanks ! ;)

I really like Castle. I just keep feeling like there is something missing from it. It feels as if every episode is stand alone. I would like it better if there were another storyline woven through the episodes. Everything is tied up too neatly in the end. Anyone else feel that way?

Amazongirl, I was upset when they canceled pushing Daisies too! Eli Stone was another good show that I think they shouldn't have canceled.
I am not loving Castle, but am liking it enough to DVR weekly. It isn't as enjoyable to me as Bones. Castle & Beckett don't have very good chemistry in my opinion, and I don't find her a very likable character- whereas I crush on Brennan as much as I do Booth. That said, there is room for growth with Castle. Nathan plays it very charming (of course) and I find the best scenes to be at home with the daughter and the mother. Glad the show is safe and will continue to watch it.
I'm actually the opposite Tinkrebel, I like Castle more than Bones which I could never come to love. I always felt that the B/B chemistry was okay but not the mecca that all the critics/fans made it out to be. And I just could never like Bones as a character.
With Castle, I definitely think there is room for improvement and the chemistry between the leads needs to be cranked up a notch but it's fun and light- an enjoyable hour of tv. I do, too, find the best scenes to be his at home with his mother and daughter. :)
I find that Castle is one of the only reasons to look forward to Mondays. It's the *sigh of relief* that the work day is over & you're that much closer to the weekend. Consider it a cookie for going to work when you could have just stayed at home. :)

This thread has been closed for new comments.

You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.

joss speaks back home back home back home back home back home