This site will work and look better in a browser that supports web standards, but it is accessible to any browser or Internet device.

Whedonesque - a community weblog about Joss Whedon
"Let's be bad guys."
11976 members | you are not logged in | 20 February 2020


September 22 2009

(SPOILER) DVD Verdict reviews Season One of Castle. "How is he not a sexist jerk-wad? Because of Fillion's performance."

I enjoyed the show alot more than I thought I would thanks to Hammer.
This review is very good. It described what makes the show so good: The dialogue, the characters, and how they're played by the actors. Thanks for posting this.
Yay. Picking mine up today. :)
Fillion is the only actor I can think of that can carry that role. He manages to be sympathetic and obnoxious at the same time. The review is right to note that the cases are secondary to the characters, and that it is this alteration that makes it stand out among other procedurals. The dialogue is razor-sharp. It reminds me quite a bit of Whedon-style dialogue, actually, which is why I probably like the show so much.
The dialogue is pretty good but to me it doesn't sound Whedonesque since it's not particularly stylised, it's not as playful with language (what playfulness there is is usually in the form of puns - i.e. closer to the way people actually make jokes - rather than the neologism heavy, linguistically stylish wisecracks of e.g. Buffy) and it's not as filled with pop culture references (though there still are some, last night's had a funny little shout-out to one of Nathan's friends and past co-stars for instance ;). S'got a Tracy/Hepburn kind of vibe more than Jossian to me.

And man am I with the reviewer in being disappointed with many of the cases on 'Castle', workmanlike at best some of them. I'm aware that story and plot are considered lesser than character to many of us on here and that to some the only good procedural is one without, y'know, procedures in it but to me mystery shows should have decent mysteries, writing good plots (especially week-in, week-out) is as much of a skill as creating interesting characters and for a show to be really great both story and character have to work together (as they always have in good procedurals).

'Castle' though very watchable and fun (largely thanks to the leads) doesn't always quite reach that for me (yet). It's still got bags of potential though and it's a well made, likable show.

This thread has been closed for new comments.

You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.

joss speaks back home back home back home back home back home