"I'm so evil, and skanky. And I think I'm kind of gay."
May 16
2012
Tom Hiddleston on BBC's The Film Programme.
A discussion with Hiddleston about a certain phrase.
From April 26, his interview is in the first 9 minutes of the program.
Slipping About
| The Avengers
| 18:40 CET
|
27 comments total
| tags: tom hiddleston, bbc, the film programme, avengers interview
This thread has been closed for new comments.
You need to
log in to be able to post comments.
About
membership.
« Older
The Avengers trailer - Lego remake!
|
Why the Avengers is the best TV sh...
Newer »
© 2002 - 2017 - WHEDONesque.com
(
e-mail)
Individual posts are copyright their respective authors
This is a non-profit, unofficial website, not affiliated with Mutant Enemy, Inc., 20th Century Fox, Warner Brothers or UPN.
A box office of over 1 billion USD, and they still can't get his name right. Sigh.
After following the lengthy discussion of "mewling quim" over at Cleolinda Jones's blog, I've come to realise just how many people were honestly offended by the admittedly archaic insult. While I don't think there's all that much merit in squeezing Ye Olde English for "whiny c---" into a blockbuster, I know having villains being misogynists is a trademark of Joss's. Eh. I'm not offended or anything, but I kind of wish people would stop being so happy it's there.
ChristyCorr | May 16, 19:00 CET
Sunder | May 16, 20:16 CET
I kinda love that after figuring it out, they didn't ask Joss to take the antiquated & offensive term out of their gigantic tentpole summer blockbuster of a movie.
(also, I was completely not offended! If the film had been slanted in agreeing with Loki that Black Widow was indeed a mewling quim, I would be outraged. But essentially an empty threat/insult from a villain who ultimately lacks conviction? Against an awesome female character? AND in Ye Olde English? That's kind of cool.)
dottikin | May 16, 20:38 CET
Bunnies | May 16, 22:00 CET
I think for Loki he thought it did, for Black Widow she might've heard worse and didn’t care, all in the line of work.
Even if you didn't understand the words, Tom played it so well you know what he intended it to be.
I think it worked, and I like Joss adding these little things as he did in Buffy/Angel/Firefly - not only does it add flavor to the character but you can guess that he’s using it to test the system lol.
Side note, I'm developing a little obsession with all things Hiddleston... saw a Russian interview with him and he listed Joss's shows as a testament of JW experience at ensembles and I just grinned and flushed like a maniac. A talented fanboy - Can we keep him, pa? Or someone should send him a link here, I bet he would be tickled to communicate with the fans the same way Joss himself chooses to do... ;p
Mirage | May 16, 22:46 CET
RBB | May 16, 22:58 CET
RobinInSeoul | May 16, 23:28 CET
I wasn't offended because I don't find gender specific language offensive - an insult is an insult. It made me laugh for the sheer audacity of including it.
And yeah, TH is becoming a bit of an addiction. His interviews are fantastic!
VicTopher | May 16, 23:52 CET
Andy Dufresne | May 17, 01:06 CET
I'm not, of course, happy that some people are getting offended. But potentially giving offence is only sometimes a reason not to say things, or include them in art (even of the more commercial variety). Some people get concerned by certain words or images in such a way that the context scarcely matters. They have their arguments for such an approach; including views about psychological and cultural influence. I find the approach deeply unhelpful, however. And I don't think that the best way to improve the world is only to produce art that represents a perfect world (whatever that would be).
The effect of Loki's murders within the fiction on real people in the audience is unsurprisingly less than the effect of his words. If we are in a reflective mood, we have reason to cast a critical eye over all human behaviour; but taking offence at fictional evil characters saying wicked things where the overall point of their having said them is to undermine those evil characters, the things said, and the ideas and practices that they drew upon - well, I think it a mistake.
Maclay | May 17, 01:46 CET
bivith | May 17, 02:31 CET
Loki is a villain. He did much worse than utilise some anglo-saxon.
Andy Dufresne | May 17, 02:39 CET
Though to reiterate, I have no problems with the insult in the Avengers on this score.
Maclay | May 17, 02:50 CET
This has drawn much less attention. Why is this? Because words are like lightening rods, and context is rarely considered. A villain did a villainous thing. If Tony Stark said the exact same thing to BW, and then laughed as he high-fived Thor, then there would be cause for concern.
Andy Dufresne | May 17, 03:02 CET
On a different note, I was puzzled that this interview referred to the film as being very long. Quite a few people have done this, yet the film isn't particularly long by today's blockbuster standards. I wonder if there is something about the film that makes it feel long for some people, or if people are more put off by the length of a film that they aren't so ready to dismiss out of hand. I don't know.
On a more joyful note, Tom Hiddleston seems deeply marvelous.
Maclay | May 17, 03:10 CET
Yes, I read your post, it's excellent. Sorry I was speaking to a broader reception.
Andy Dufresne | May 17, 03:20 CET
Maclay | May 17, 03:31 CET
As for the insult, I agree with what people here have said. It's all about context. And the word not only comes from the mouth of a villain, but it's used in the very scene where Black Widow gets the better of him. He's trying to target her gender to weaken her, but it does not faze her.
Bluelark | May 17, 03:50 CET
Why is this a problem? :/ lol.
FangedFourLover | May 17, 04:15 CET
garyyager | May 17, 04:28 CET
Hiddleston had Loki literally frothing at the mouth when he dropped the "q" word.
This movie had zero uses of the "f" word, and probably could have gotten away with two uses and still kept a PG-13 rating. It would have been appropriate for the Loki's emotions if he called BW a "f***ing b***h", but those words would have been wrong coming out of Loki's mouth. Joss found the correct way to have Loki be vile, insulting, *and* in character.
OneTeV | May 17, 05:44 CET
QingTing | May 17, 07:20 CET
I read through the cleolinda thread on this subject (linked above) and was surprised at how many people were offended and thought that this language showed misogyny in the film, rather than in the character. But this is an ongoing issue in popular film criticism: showing us an instance of misogyny in a context that makes the audience see it for what it is (put it in a villain's mouth) is a very different thing from being unthinkingly misogynistic (or racist or classist or or ...), but it's a tricky wire to walk and writers get it wrong much more often than they get it right, trying to be edgy or something I think. Audiences are right to be wary.
I was not offended by this scene, at all, but I was quite offended by (for example) a scene in the trailer for the latest Adam Sandler movie, in which we see a young woman call her fiancé a "big vagina" (meaning, in the context, wimp, whiner). Having a woman say it doesn't make it okay and doesn't make it funny, guys. It just makes her an unthinking re-inscriber of the values of her oppressors.
However, having the villain say it in a context that uses that language to show that he's a monster, as here, is a different thing.
lbowman | May 17, 07:22 CET
I love how hard he loves Joss. Wonder if he knows about the Shakespeare readings at the Whedon's?
Willowy | May 17, 07:23 CET
At what point does an insult become so archaic that it loses its sting? If I remember my history, "yankee doodle" was a nasty insult at the time, but wouldn't bat an eye nowadays.
OneTeV | May 17, 07:44 CET
@Andy Dufresne I concur with it all. The fact is, our villain is the one who threatens and subjugates BW. Our heroes immediately accept her as an equal, and don't sexualize nor pidgeonhole her. Even in Iron Man 2, first time she comes on screen, RDJ and Jon Favreau are checking her out while flipping through photos of her in lingerie. In Avengers, she's just one of the team. Not "the other woman". Not eye candy. Not anyone's love/lust interest.
I look at teams in The Avengers, Inception, the Ocean's Twelve sequels, and I have to wonder... how many more action films are going to have the token female character on the team (if even that) before there are just men and women working side by side? It'll probably take a while.
WhatsAStevedore | May 17, 08:01 CET
lbowman | May 19, 12:53 CET