March 24
2005
Marti Noxon confirms Point Pleasant cancelation.
American Idol results this Thursday. Tru Calling thereafter.
Ocipital
| Cast&Crew
| 01:05 CET
|
72 comments total
| tags:
You need to
log in to be able to post comments.
About
membership.
« Older
BTVSFigs' Ask Diamond 22
|
Some things onscreen are best left...
Newer »
© 2002 - 2008 - WHEDONesque.com
(
e-mail)
Individual posts are copyright their respective authors
This is a non-profit, unofficial website, not affiliated with Mutant Enemy, Inc., 20th Century Fox, Warner Brothers or UPN.
Gunn 2 N's | March 24, 01:15 CET
April | March 24, 01:19 CET
Harmalicious | March 24, 01:21 CET
I agree. Well, hopefully she'll move on to bigger and better things now. Emphasis on the "better". Not to be mean...I'm just sayin'. I'm sure she learned some things from Point Pleasant and I have high hopes for her.
VampiresSuckLOLOLGetIt | March 24, 01:23 CET
charisma | March 24, 01:28 CET
Angela | March 24, 01:32 CET
anyways, best of luck marti.
rsfayez | March 24, 01:34 CET
Good luck in the future for whatever you do in the future Marti!
Apocalypse | March 24, 01:50 CET
MandyMouse | March 24, 01:56 CET
Firefly Flanatic | March 24, 02:10 CET
WWBD | March 24, 02:14 CET
Anyway, kudos to Marti. She tried her best, it didn't work out and I hope she finds a new show very shortly.
Simon | March 24, 02:19 CET
Kaine | March 24, 02:25 CET
redtenko | March 24, 02:26 CET
Rogue | March 24, 02:27 CET
www.fox.com/pointpleasant? Nope not any more .
Simon | March 24, 02:29 CET
Wow, the website has gone already, Simon? Fox really don't waste any time in distancing themselves from cancelled shows to they!
Kaine | March 24, 02:32 CET
Simon | March 24, 02:33 CET
Kaine | March 24, 02:39 CET
Caroline | March 24, 02:42 CET
It should just be a policy that if a show is given the green light to air it should be allowed to finish out it's season and given time to wrap up the storyline if it isn't coming back for a second season.
Firefly Flanatic | March 24, 02:42 CET
Marti, I feel your pain.
Is it too late to move to Europe?
Maeve | March 24, 02:43 CET
Melisande | March 24, 02:44 CET
If this were a fair and just world, that would be so.
Fox is on some sort of pattern. Shows like Firefly, Point Pleasant. Wonderfalls and Tru Calling are obvious examples. There may be others. Fox shows a new series for awhile and if the ratings aren't what they like right out the gate, they cancel it without showing all the episodes, then come out later with a DVD set that includes those episodes not shown, thus giving people ample reason to buy said DVD sets. If I didn't know any better, and come to think of it I don't, I'd think they were doing this on purpose to insure a higher increase in said DVD sales. Is this shrewd business dealings, or are we all just saps for an elaborate corporate scam? Whether it's a scam or shrewdness, I think it's just flat stupid. Any successful tv series goes through a couple years where it tries to find its audience. Seinfeld went through name changes and a lot of creative turmoil before it became one of the most successful tv series of the 1990s. Star Trek Next Generation didn't get its sea legs until late in the first season with the re-introduction of the Romulans. The first year of Happy Days looks dramatically different from the more successful years of the series. The people running Fox have not studied the history of their own industry. You can't pull out of such an investment in less than one season without guaranteeing you lose your shirt. I can't imagine them doing this for any other reason than the belief that DVD sales will outdo any advertising profits they could get by keeping it on the air.
In short, the Fox network executives are a bunch of shee-niou chiang-BAO HOE-tze duh tah-shr SUO-yo DEE-yure duh biao-tze duh MAH! Huh choo-shung tza-jiao duh tzang-huo! Tyen-sah duh UH-muo! Lao TYEN yeh! Tai-kong suo-yo duh shing-chiou sai-jin wuh duh pee-goo! Dong-ma?! Tzao-gao! Tah mah duh hwoon dahn! HOE-tze duh PEE-goo!
Changing the subject deliberately (while staying on topic for the thread), Marti Noxon was responsible for producing season six of Buffy, easily my FAVORITE season of the seven year run of the series. She's a talented producer. I remember people dissing Noxon during season six because they didn't like how dark the series had become under her wing, but I thought it was great! Season six is the Empire Strikes Back of the Buffy series. Great work. Entertaining and enlightening. Thought-provoking fun. My favorite kinda entertainment - the kind that makes you think.
Marti Noxon should be proud of her accomplishments and I'm sure she'll be successful in whatever the future has in store for her, WhedonVerse or no.
ZachsMind | March 24, 03:04 CET
GrrrAargh | March 24, 03:08 CET
[ edited by electricspacegirl on 2005-03-24 01:50 ]
electricspacegirl | March 24, 03:28 CET
Sorry, wasn't clear. Apparently there was a graphical error on American Idol last night, basically they didn't put the correct phone numbers to vote on. So they are re-doing Tuesdays episode again (a new live episode but exactly the same as yesterdays, not technically a repeat but getting there). This then pushed the results show to Thursday, with TC already being scheduled on Thursday for the following 3 weeks (two eps a night), Fox decided to simply cancel PP (which previously may have seen out May sweeps) That's my interpretation anyway
Ocipital | March 24, 03:36 CET
PP was getting better. I saw the episode about the dance written by Zack Estrin (Charmed,Miracles, and he also wrote the best episodes of Tru Calling) and that was much better than the sappy teen stories it start out with.
I'm hoping the fans do get sock puppet theater. Maybe if there is enough demand for the DVD, that could be a bonus feature.
FaithFan | March 24, 03:49 CET
melsta | March 24, 03:50 CET
Ocular | March 24, 03:56 CET
chinesevery badly pronounced mandarin, but has been sacked by the censors. Those reponsible for sacking Zach have also been sacked. Thank you. Try vacationing in Sweden this year, ja? It's very nice.][ edited by ZachsMind on 2005-03-24 02:30 ]
ZachsMind | March 24, 04:28 CET
norman | March 24, 05:09 CET
eddy | March 24, 05:34 CET
Craig Oxbrow | March 24, 05:35 CET
When Tru Calling and Point Pleasant were cancelled? Eh, not so much. I never got into either.
Regardless, it's sad simply because Noxon was involved, and I'm a fan. I feel bad for her, because, damnit, season 6 was the best.
Hopefully she goes on to greater things in TV land.
/me watches Wrecked.
Gonnas | March 24, 06:40 CET
adventures in spelling | March 24, 08:38 CET
What a great way to put it! Season 6 was my favorite season of Buffy, also.
Cancelling Point Pleasant was inevitable, but it was getting better. I also liked the last episode. It did almost feel like an episode of "Buffy."
Among the problems with the show were characters I couldn't care about, and a main character who was so out-of-focus, it was impossible to identify with her. In Buffy and Angel, essentially WE were Buffy, or WE were Angel as we watched these shows. We experienced what they experienced, and felt what they felt. They were the metaphoric representations of US. When we couldn't identify with them, there were other characters so richly developed, we became those characters. Who among us wasn't Willow or Xander or Spike or Wesley at some point as we watched? This was the case from the very first episode of Buffy. It didn't take several episodes to warm up to these characters. They grabbed us from the start.
THAT didn't happen in Point Pleasant.
Nebula1400 | March 24, 08:54 CET
I left Point Pleasant after a few episodes as it didn't quite do it for me, but as others have written I will be there with my pom-poms supporting Marti's next project, so good luck to her.
Bill Door | March 24, 11:33 CET
Here's her in message in full:
Just want to thank those of you who like the show for your support and fill you in on a few facts. The show has actually been creeping up in the ratings with
adults every week for the last three weeks. We're going down in teens, which is a bummer - but the fact is, this was designed to be more of an
adult show. All this to say - now is the time to MAKE YOUR VOICE HEARD
if you like the show. Get on internet sites and e-mail critics - ain't it cool, zap to it, etc... Bug FOX! Tell them the show rocks now (if you think it does) and that they should be paying attention.
All of us here at PP feel like the show is worth saving. We're all having such fun writing it and acting it and making it. Yeah, we got off to a bumpy start - agreed. And some eps will be better than others - but I'm proud of what we're making here now. And where things are going - pretty twisted...
PLEASE, please,please... Tell people to watch, make a fuss - and you can make a real difference!
Thanks again.
Simon | March 24, 13:18 CET
From what I've seen for PP it seems clear that TV show's must hook their intended target audience within the first 4-5 episodes, if they dont they will be replaced. By the 5th episode the audience, the journalists and the tv networks have made up their mind whether a show is a keeper or not, saving the good stuff for later only ensures that your DVD's are remembered fondly.
No need to speak badly about Sweden, we are depressed enough as it is around here, even if things are starting to look up now that spring is arriving, the snow is melting away and there is hope of sunshine sometime soon.
For TV addicts being on a permanent six month delay for most series and missing out completely on others will make you even more depressed but DVD's can be lifesavers.
ZM, Your theory regarding saving episodes for the DVD's is probably spot on and yes in the summer Sweden definitely is a nice vacation spot.
ais, I believe the golden rule applies to moose as well. If you treat the moose nice they'll treat you nice, if not you get what you deserve.
I still prefer S3 to S6.
My reasons for thinking less about season 6 than previous seasons is based on the fact that by then I had invested a lot in the 'take charge' Buffy, Buffy as the super hero. The relentlessly downbeat season 6 where every character in one way or another proved to be less than they could be left me with the feeling that in the season where the big bad was described as 'life itself' they lost the fight or at best achieved a draw. Might be realistic but it left me feeling sorry for them and with no one I wanted to identify with.
I am actually a big fan of the darkness in Buffy and Angel, bad things happening to good people on a regular basis does make for good tv, but it requires a fine balance.
Much of the difference to me lies in who is in control of the situation, in most of S3 Buffy is in control, in S5 'Checkpoint' she is very much in control, in most of S6 she is not in control of events and neither are any of the rest of the gang.
In S7 Buffy is back in the drivers seat, to many speeches maybe but also a 'Showtime' and 'Chosen' to balance it out. My selective memory skips Buffy getting kicked out of her own home, I choose to read it as her needing to leave the useless hangers-on behind to recharge her batteries and go kick some Caleb butt. Not exactly what was shown on screen but I guess a(nother) speech by Buffy where she tells the potentials and her friends how useless they are and then leaves the house would have gone against the theme of the season. In the tradition of 'show not tell' writing they instead get the chance to show exactly how useless they are until Buffy comes back and saves them.
jpr | March 24, 14:06 CET
In the meantime, picnic in Marti’s back garden it is then. I hope there will be an episode where puppet Angel fights sock puppet devil and, just to cheer Marti up, James and his sock gets thrown into the mix.
BTW, Sweden is a very nice place, well worth visiting. I used to work for a Swedish company and go to Stockholm all the time. Never got used to that funny pinky fishegg stuff you all go on about though. What’s up with that?
miranda | March 24, 16:50 CET
'Course, I hadn't gone there in several weeks, maybe no one else did either. *sigh*
April | March 24, 17:14 CET
It's a bit unfair to be complaining here. Point Pleasant was a show that was given everything. It even had a goddam American Idol lead-in. Yet despite this, it haemorraged viewers from episode 1. Can you imagine if it had lasted a whole season? Compared to Firefly's 15 eps? Considering just how much Point Pleasant sucked, it just wouldn't have been fair.
The only thing you can blame Fox for here is that they approved Noxon's script in the first place.
As for Noxon's next show, I wouldn't hold my breath.
She's not like the other buffy writers. If you look at the other writers, you'll find that they had writing careers before buffy, and from what I've seen, they wrote well.
Look at Noxon's imdb page. She began at Buffy. Her only writing acheivements of note were in the first three seasons of Buffy, by her own admission years heavily guided by Joss. Since then, what has she done? One movie, by all accounts unremarkable to be kind. One rejected pilot. And of course Point Pleasant.
She is not capable of running a show on her own, and never has been.
Her only talent so far has been drawing material from a very screwed up relationships. But while that's good for writing the odd episode of angstiness, it can't sustain a whole season. Or even half of one.
Dym | March 24, 17:17 CET
Oh well, we all see these things differently. Personally, I find Noxon quite inspirational. It saddens me that 'Point Pleasant' didn't work out and I hope it won't be too long before something new comes along.
alien lanes | March 24, 18:02 CET
*Start commercial* Can ususally be found together with Swedish meatballs at your local IKEA store. *end commercial*
jpr | March 24, 18:48 CET
MySerenity | March 24, 19:16 CET
Inspirational?
Could you explain?
Dym | March 24, 20:58 CET
I love Season Six. How much credit goes to Marti I don't know. Most people here talk as though Joss simply dropped off the planet for that season, but, busy as he was, everything I've read suggests he was setting all the themes and major developments of the season and reviewing all the scripts. So I think we really haven't seen Marti on her own before. Not to say PP was indicative of her talent, just that she hasn't had the practice martialing a talented group of people to achieve her vision.
Edit: Dym, if he's talking about S6, I'd say it was an amazingly inspirational arc. Doing away with the Big Bad was incredibly courageous move, and it showed us what real, believable human evil looks like in Warren: small, petty, contemptible even in its capacity for horrifying destructiveness. And removing the pressure of saving the world allowed the flaws we all knew the characters had to finally emerge unrestrained. They almost ate the characters alive, in fact. But at the end of the day, the characters triumphed. They faced the very worst of themselves and each other, and survived it all. That, too me, is endlessly more inspirational than killing a giant snake.
[ edited by Andarcel on 2005-03-24 19:21 ]
[ edited by Andarcel on 2005-03-24 19:22 ]
Andarcel | March 24, 21:13 CET
In my opinion, the ideas for s6 were good. I don't believe in the "too dark" school of thought. However, it was just so shoddily executed. My greatest disappointment about season 6 was that with the themes they were trying to introduce, it could have been brilliant. Yet someone managed to take those ideas and create such utter crap.
It's much the same with Point Pleasant. The ideas weren't that bad. This show could have been great. But it was just so shoddily executed from day 1.
See the pattern?
Dym | March 24, 22:00 CET
SoddingNancyTribe | March 24, 22:11 CET
Sorry, Dym, have to disagree. Nothing I've seen from Joss, especially anything on Buffy the Vampire Slayer, has ever qualified as "crap".
I personally enjoyed season 6 tremendously. Three is my favorite, but that's neither here nor there. And I don't think PP ever came close to even the least of BtVS's episodes.
Willowy | March 24, 22:13 CET
I wonder what the ratings for the unaired episodes of Tru Calling will be? To me, it was a much more entertaining show.
brownishcoat | March 24, 23:02 CET
MySerenity | March 24, 23:27 CET
Madhatter | March 24, 23:47 CET
Simon said:
“Thing is I was really enjoying the episode too and felt the show was finally getting into the swing of things. In case any US posters are wondering which episode it was, it was one where Boyd gets tied to the chair and gets doped up on a truth drug. It almost felt like I was watching a Buffy episode.”
Almost. It *was* the first episode where I felt a real sense of suspense and a desire to know more about some of the characters and their moral and mental dilemmas. Still couldn’t bear most of the acting, but I think the directing was exceptional. The director of that episode, James Contner, had directed episodes of Firefly, Angel and Buffy, if I’m not mistaken. If PP was “designed to be more of an adult show”, I wish it had given that impression in the beginning instead of starting out like Satan does the OC. Oh, well, too late now.
I’m sure everyone involved in making the show is feeling pretty crappy right now, but I know Marti will succeed at something else and I wish her all the best.
bloodflowers | March 24, 23:51 CET
Probably not, to be honest, without boring the pants off everyone with details of my background, both persoanl and professional. I do find Marti Noxon an inspiration and I have a huge amount of admiration for her. I find the criticism she receives for her handling of S6 utterly mystifying... on the subject of which, Adarcel, I thought your explanation was excellent (thanks for that).
In my opinion, the ideas for s6 were good. I don't believe in the "too dark" school of thought. However, it was just so shoddily executed. My greatest disappointment about season 6 was that with the themes they were trying to introduce, it could have been brilliant. Yet someone managed to take those ideas and create such utter crap.
I couldn't disagree more, but everyone has there own opinions about these things.
alien lanes | March 24, 23:51 CET
I did think there was a difference in execution and coherence, as opposed tot the grandeur that was S2 and 3 (and parts of S1), but I rather blamed it on budget and some kind of seven year itch. No show is perfect from start to finish, the stars don't always align that way. Firefly was great, but had it continued, inevitably there would have come a point where it wouldn't have been great anymore.
Point Pleasant needed more time. Perhaps a lot more time. Perhaps a different cast. Perhaps fewer characters. But there is no time anymore. In the same way that young bands don't get to make a dodgy second album anymore, it's one strike you're out in TV these days.
Here's a crazy idea to cheat and give yourself more time. Perhaps TV makers could take a different approach... take their story to the stage first. Work the cast in front of an audience until they have their parts down pat and the ensemble has gelled. Recast if necessary. Then start filming TV episodes. Gives the show a head start. (Probably unfeasible, too expensive. What do I know about TV making. Nothing.)
Caroline | March 25, 00:16 CET
Dym, its already unfair that PP and TC both outlasted Wondefalls!
eddy | March 25, 00:31 CET
Christopher | March 25, 01:10 CET
I for one am a fan of Marti. I do understand what you mean, Dym. Having the slayer as a less than "ass kicker" so far along in the series was quite a risk. But, Marti and Joss had to balance out the hugeness of her death. It wasn't an easy fix, Willow brings her back...all is good...let's stake some vamps...yum cookies. Doesn't work that way. All the characters dealt with some heavy stuff that year and Marti and Joss did a superb job at grounding the season putting life at the center of evil.
Marti, grab Jane, Doug, and/or Drew and get this Spike movie going! We are behind you every step of the way!!
Harmalicious | March 25, 01:27 CET
The second time through was when it came on BBC 2 and again i found that it wasn't working for me. It wasn't until i got the DVD set that season six really kicked into gear for me. Not being limited to waiting whole weeks between episodes it didn't feel so disjointed and the character development seemed a lot more fluid. I won't pretend it is my favourite season of the series but i still very much enjoy watching it now.
Well, except Doublemeat Palace, but i have a detest of all McDonalds/Burger King type places and so watching Buffy working in one really didn't work for me. Is it just me or would anyone else have chosen working in the Magic Box to working in that grease pit any day of the week?
Kaine | March 25, 02:54 CET
nixygirl | March 25, 03:16 CET
The Doublemeat Palace thing really didn't work for me because I felt there was no reason at all to be there. I'm sure Marti's excuse would be something along the lines of "well, season 6 was about pain and suffering," though, right?
Christopher | March 25, 04:01 CET
Like you say though, Christopher, there was the option of working at the Magic Box that Buffy most likely could have gone back to at any time. Giles certainly would have left the position open, regardless of whether he was there himself or not. Okay, Anya may not have been the easiest person to have had as your boss but between working for her in a nice clean shop, with all the training and research benefits on hand as you mentioned, and the other option of flipping burgers and coming home stinking of greasy food? Well, for me the choice would be very easy indeed.
Kaine | March 25, 04:22 CET
Season 6 hooked me on Buffy in reruns because I appreciated the serious exploration of something I had not really seen on TV before. I do not consider it a mess by a long shot. Even so, I find it strange that people make judgements and lay blame for what they did not like about the season without having been part of the process to see what actually happened. Marti Noxon is obviously talented. What she is or is not capable in the future is totally conjecture. What exactly happened during Season 6, like each person's opinion of it, is also opinion, with rumor, and conjecture thrown in for good measure.
I wish MN well, I'm sure she will find the place that is right for her.
newcj | March 25, 04:53 CET
Once I got to see it uninterrupted I could appreciate how great it was.
And Buffy not wanting to work at the Magic Box made a lot of sense. She felt alone and isolated from the group and she really didn't want to remedy that. Working at the DoubleMeat palace gave her the opportunity to get away from everyone. Remember she not only saw them there all the time but she saw most of them at home too.
[ edited by Firefly Flanatic on 2005-03-25 04:59 ]
Firefly Flanatic | March 25, 06:58 CET
Koos | March 25, 13:08 CET
Send yourself to a hell dimension, fine! Walk weaponless into a nest of fifty extremely powerful vampire, sure! But work in a burger joint? Wow, Buffy REALLY must have hated herself! :)
Kaine | March 25, 13:59 CET
I can't believe the networks cancel a show and don't follow through with airing the remaining episodes. What about all those major cliffhangers?? They have no respect for their viewers!
I really hate investing time in a show to have it yanked off the air. Granted, the show was pretty awful for a while, but it was just starting to become really good.
Well, why would I expect anything more from FOX? It's there M.O.
Do you think a DVD will be released? (I really don't want to buy a DVD of the entire season. I do want to see the final episodes since I invested time in watching every episode of PP since it's inception, good or bad, hoping it would improve.) Gosh darn it!
creepy6 | March 25, 21:16 CET
I haven´t seen the series so... i can´t comment.
I hope she will get a job as soon as possible.
Angel TheVampire | March 26, 00:31 CET
I think the WB gave me a complex.
twiggy | March 27, 05:22 CET
The downside of that, of course, is that you end up not really watching anything at all. Knowing that a show will most likely be cancelled in the near future doesn't give you any incentive to try it out when it finally starts airing.
Kaine | March 27, 05:30 CET