The fans decide - Yay or Nay for Serenity?
Well the tickets for tonight's screenings sold out so fast, it almost cracked the internet in half. Anyhow 35 screenings in North America, were you one of the lucky ones to get a ticket? Come tell us what you thought of Serenity in this non-spoiler thread.
Spot the pop-culture reference above and win a prize *probably or more likely probably not*.
So no spoilers at all in this thread, not even in invisible text.
June 24 2005
You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.


gtman8503 | June 24, 05:03 CET
Do I win?
Okkay | June 24, 05:11 CET
But on the otherhand, I'm thinking it's the Charlie and the Chocolate Factory reference.
I can't wait to hear what people thought of the screening tonight. It's the only thing that can make up for unlucky people like me who haven't even seen Serenity once. I just start salivating at the mouth when I read your guys' (non-spoiler!!) reviews.
riaspark17 | June 24, 06:52 CET
Knuckleball | June 24, 07:12 CET
By the way, the final tally on ebay was over 300 sales amounting to over $15,000 !
[ edited by TaraLivesOn on 2005-06-24 05:45 ]
TaraLivesOn | June 24, 07:38 CET
Oh and Chris B. (the exec producer) was there. That was cool.
eddy | June 24, 09:03 CET
So, um, when can I see it again?
vamRIPire | June 24, 09:10 CET
I really looks like a Big Damn Movie now!
I brought two Joss "virgins" with me this time. One, my son, liked it a lot, and now wants to watch my "firefly" DVDs.
His girlfriend was a little less enthused. She didn't dislike it, but she said that it was a little difficult to get into all the characters and felt she needed to see "Firefly" beforehand to understand them better. She said she thought it would be a hit with sci-fi fans, but wasn't sure if a more general audience would like it.
[ edited by Nebula1400 on 2005-06-24 07:34 ]
Nebula1400 | June 24, 09:22 CET
It have a confession. I liked Firefly, but I did not love it. I thought it had a lot going for it and would have liked to see where it went in future episodes and seasons, but I was not in love with it. I wanted to see Serenity because I love Joss's work, was excited about what he would do when let loose, and was tired of trying to avoid spoilers. Well, I loved this movie. I had a great time. I still want to see where these characters are going in the future and how they are going to get there, but I also feel satisfied...for now. I was also ready to see it again right away because I felt like I missed so much.
I did not meet anyone there who had never seen Firefly so I do not know their reaction. The audience in general seemed to like it a lot.
I know you have heard this before, but for those who have not seen it, resist spoilers!! Even if you think you have been accidently spoiled, don't assume you have. I thought I had, but it was a lie. I had told myself it probably was a lie, but was afraid it was not. I was lucky. You might be too, so keep away from the spoiler threads even if you think it is too late for you.
Oh, and Morena was there tonight, lovely and gracious.
newcj | June 24, 09:29 CET
For those who haven't seen it, I echo the plea above - stay unspoiled. I had been accidently spoiled a bit but the movie just delivers surprise after surprise. It is a lot more of an "action-adventure" movie than I expected but the Joss wit is still very much there.
I could see a few rough effects and someone else swore she heard the theme from Jaws, probably as a place holder but other than that, it looked pretty finished.
Lioness | June 24, 09:38 CET
Chris inVirginia | June 24, 09:47 CET
As for what i thought of the movie: *thud*
Lunakitty | June 24, 09:52 CET
Firefly Flanatic | June 24, 09:53 CET
By the by. Damn you all. I'm sooooooo jealous, especially you NY/Jersey people.
nychick | June 24, 09:58 CET
Firefly Flanatic | June 24, 10:04 CET
Domi | June 24, 10:27 CET
TaraLivesOn | June 24, 10:28 CET
I'm so desperate to see that...
pir2 | June 24, 10:38 CET
Anyone have a complete city/celeb list yet?
TaraLivesOn | June 24, 10:48 CET
GrrrAargh | June 24, 10:52 CET
Anyways, great movie. My mom liked it, and she's so totally far away from fandom so if she 'gets' it, than just about anyone could get it.
lalaa | June 24, 11:04 CET
And, stay unspoiled. You'll thank yourself. I thought this was, 100 times the movie Sith was.
k8cre8 | June 24, 11:14 CET
lalaa | June 24, 11:17 CET
TaraLivesOn | June 24, 11:32 CET
eddy | June 24, 11:36 CET
This movie gets better every. single. time. The new reel was fantastic - the grain and light problems all fixed and shiny. And while there was a group, including myself, seeing it a third time, there were far more people seeing it for the first time. The repeat viewers clearly brought in friends, family, and a new group of Browncoats. That much was obvious from audience reactions.
Angela | June 24, 11:41 CET
We had banana bread and brownies :)
eddy | June 24, 11:59 CET
The movie was good too. I'm really tired.
SoddingNancyTribe | June 24, 12:37 CET
Joss was awesome and signed mini-posters and anything else everyone wanted while we were entering the theater. He even personalized them if you asked, but of course I was too in awe to ask. I did manage to tell him that he rocked, to which he replied, "I rock a little. Then I rest 'cause I'm tired from rocking so much. And then I rock some more." I don't know how that man is so witty all the time. He talked a little before the movie. He said he spent the day with a full orchestra (who played "Happy Birthday" for him) recording the score for the film. Then we all sang "Happy Birthday" to him. Then the movie with the same intro from the other screenings. I didn't notice any changes from when I saw it on May 5th, except that it looked a lot better. He answered five questions after the movie 'cause he was sleepy. =)
This was the second time I've flown 500 miles to see a screening of Serenity and it was totally worth it. I brought my friend who I converted into a semi-Browncoat last year and his girlfriend who's not into sci-fi at all. My friend really liked the movie and his girlfriend thought "it was very exciting."
Did any other cities get these really cool 3-page fold-out handouts that explain how the movie came to be, bios on our 9 BDH, a bio on Joss, and a shiny full-page photo of the crew on Serenity (minus Book and Inara)?
einral | June 24, 13:42 CET
TaraLivesOn | June 24, 13:50 CET
It's super shiny. Nice little blurbs about Joss, his history, and a little section for each actor.
lalaa | June 24, 14:02 CET
I thought I was spoiled but it turned out to be a lie. Kind of half true. So maybe if you read the same accidental stuff I did, you're not spoiled after all. Definite wild ride and somehow funnier than I anticipated. Ups n downs all throughout, and we were glad we came in unspoiled. I don't think anyone even got up to go to the bathroom. You couldn't. Anything could happen whenever. Scariness. Action. The best Whedon scene ever. All the good stuff.
Pretty much the best movie I've seen since I have no idea when. Thanks to the Browncoats who had the banner! We got programs and keychains :) !!
It's true what they say. It's our BDHs, and they are just so BIG! Nathan Fillion shall be a household name. Oh, there were editing issues... and I thought about it for maybe three seconds.
Joss' message just seemed so sincere and heartfelt. God, I love that man!
April | June 24, 14:12 CET
Riverside: Joss
Houston: Summer Glau
Phoenix: Nathan Fillion (nice photos)
Charlotte: Chris Buchanan
NYC/NJ: Morena Baccarin
Miami: Gina Torres
Boston: Loni Peristere (Zoic)
Toronto: Sean Maher
Indianapolis: Ron Glass
Vancouver: Jewel Staite
we are missing Alan Tudyk and Adam Baldwin?
[ edited by TaraLivesOn on 2005-06-24 18:50 ]
TaraLivesOn | June 24, 15:38 CET
binkaboo | June 24, 15:40 CET
I'm in Cleveland but I was on vacation when the big announcement came, so I couldn't even try for tickets. How was the crowd?
melsta | June 24, 16:30 CET
Nebula1400 | June 24, 16:54 CET
TaraLivesOn | June 24, 17:08 CET
I was spoiler-free (except for the trailer), and I was SOOOOOOO glad I was. The movie was a thrill ride. Since I had not seen the print from earlier screenings that others have mentioned, I cannot compare, but I did think there were some sound issues and a couple of places that I thought the CGI wasn't quite working. But, even if these problems weren't fixed, this would be one heck of a movie. The cast looked great, and the acting was top-notch. And the writing -- well, Joss is at the top of his form. The audience was right there with him, with laughter and shrieks in all the right places. Because everything was so fast-paced and tightly packed, there sometimes wasn't enough time for the audience to laugh and still hear the next line -- but that's what DVDs are for, aren't they?
I left the theater thinking maybe one might need to have seen some of Firefly to really get into the movie, but, as April said, one of our group had seen only three eps (and he said he had been multitasking throughout, so he had not concentrated on them), and he was raving about the film afterwards. So I felt a little better on that score after talking with him -- and I see from other postings that others new to the 'verse enjoyed the film, so I hope my initial impressions were wrong.
I do want to see the film again and again and again. And I want sequels. I had a fantastic time -- was so happy to be among other fans and a highly partisan audience -- got to sign the birthday banner and participate in the videotaped Happy Birthday singing -- got my keychain and beautiful fold-out brochure -- purchased some fan-made souvenirs (Universal, get the goodies out there for fans to purchase -- you're losing revenue!). This was one of the most enjoyable days I've had in a long time. Thank you, Joss!
palehorse | June 24, 19:26 CET
nixygirl | June 24, 19:47 CET
Of course, that's just our luck. We didn't go because we figured your ticket would have been given away by the time we got there!! :(
Ah well, I'd have been exhausted today at work anyway. That's the justification I'm using now to make it okay...
Rogue Slayer | June 24, 20:04 CET
Genia | June 24, 20:41 CET
[ edited by einral on 2005-06-24 19:31 ]
einral | June 24, 21:30 CET
k8cre8 | June 24, 22:02 CET
zeitgeist | June 24, 22:35 CET
Miko | June 25, 00:19 CET
No problem. I've seen it once in Joss' presence, so I'm not completely deprived! :)
Rogue Slayer | June 25, 00:47 CET
Anyway, I am hoping to see most of the crew in three weeks in San Diego.
impalergeneral | June 25, 01:22 CET
400lb_Gorilla | June 25, 01:29 CET
Rob | June 25, 01:49 CET
Hi, my name is Joss Whedon. Before we begin the special screening, I have a little story I want to tell you. It's about a TV show called Firefly.
Firefly went on the air a few years ago and was instantly hailed by critics as one of the most canceled shows of the year. It was ignored and abandoned and the story should end there, but it doesn't, because the people who made the show and the people who saw the show (which is...roughly...the same number of people) fell in love with it a little bit...too much to let it go, too much to lay down arms when the battle looked pretty much lost. In Hollywood, people like that are called 'unrealistic' ... 'quixotic' ... 'obsessive'.
In my world, they're called 'Browncoats'.
Whether you've watched the show, or saw the DVD's, or whether you've never set foot in the Firefly universe before tonight, the fact that you're here means that you are part of something...something that is a little bit remarkable. This movie should not exist. Failed TV shows don't get made into major motion pictures unless the creator, the cast, and the fans believe beyond reason.
It's what I've felt. It's what I've seen...in the DVD sales, the booths at the cons run by fans, the websites, the fundraisers... all the work the fans have done to help make this movie. It is, in an unprecedented sense, your movie...which means, if it sucks, it's your fault. You let us down, but let's not dwell on your failures because the work is not done. I have to finish making it. Obviously not quite the final cut and you will notice some placeholders in music and effects, but we're very close. Once we are finished, we have to get people to see it. Now, obviously the studio is going to do their thing. There will be ads and trailers and all that joy, but this movie doesn't have stars and it doesn't have a giant mega-budget or even a simple salable premise. What it has is us, the people who believed unreasonably.
If this movie matters to you, let somebody know. Let everybody know. Make yourselves heard. If you don't like the movie, this is a time for quite, silent contemplation. But, when the unfinished credits roll, if you still call yourself a Browncoat, remember the millions of people who don't...who might. I want us to do this together. The cast is going to be appearing wherever they can. I'm going to be blogging and stumping and whatever I can think of. We've got Can'tStopTheSignal.com up and running...I'm fairly certain. We're all doing everything we can to make this the event that it should be.
Just remember, they tried to kill us...they did kill us...and here we are. We have done the impossible, and that makes us mighty. Thank you for helping to get this movie as far as it has gotten.
Welcome to Serenity.
Kessie | June 25, 02:12 CET
400lb_Gorilla | June 25, 02:45 CET
The crowd was great, very friendly and we had a few girls who sang the theme, and made a go at "Hero of Canton"- a guy dressed as Jayne also stood up with a cry of "To the mudders! To ME!" A lot of fun, even though we lacked any of the cast, but we gave a round of applause to the Universal rep when he apologized for it. =)
kishi | June 25, 05:25 CET
"After the film ended Ron Glass came to the front to take any questions we had and to ask for reactions. As someone eventually said "We're quiet because we're still taking it in." Speaking for myself I was also pretty tired by that point. Several people asked him about his role, Book's backstory, what he thought about acting in the ensemble, about acting with them again, what his reaction to the script had been, what reactions the other actors had, etc. One person apparently had parents who had known Ron in high school, having acted with him in "John Brown's Body" and had told their son stories. He sssshhh'ed the guy and when he told Ron he was happy to finally meet him, Ron replied "Obviously they've been telling the right stories!" He was asked what he was doing now and he talked about working with the Miss USA pageant, being on a lecture circuit and having to write an essay about how education has affected his life. He said he got the assignment in October, had holiday plans and so postponed working on it, and is now realizing he still has nothing written! He had spent several hours that day with a former 5th grade teacher who is still working at a high school.
He then said goodbye and as we left we were all given keychains, a flyer and a fold-out brochure on the film. In the lobby there was a poster for Joss's birthday which we both signed."
yourlibrarian | June 25, 05:57 CET
also:
Photos of Joss at Riverside screening
Near the bottom. He looks really young for 41.
[ edited by TaraLivesOn on 2005-06-25 08:48 ]
TaraLivesOn | June 25, 10:08 CET
palehorse | June 25, 14:17 CET
miranda | June 25, 14:49 CET
RavenU | June 25, 15:14 CET
Lioness | June 25, 16:54 CET
Genia | June 25, 21:43 CET
Indeed as yourlibrarian wrote above, one audience member's parents had worked with Ron in high school and the movie I took of that is simply awsome as you see Ron's open mouth look of awe. Too cool. I was astonished and humbled at Ron's willingness to spent upwards of a half-hour with us answering questions...and it was after midnight!
Direct questions about Book's backstory were properly deflected as I believe Ron either didn't know specifics or had been instructed not to share details. Similar questions about movie events were deflected as well. I shall not post spoilery specifics. A fan asked if there was more than one verson of the Advance Screening of Serenity and Ron's answer was this: "There might be a couple of (he pauses) a couple of versions...you know..(another pause) Just little slight differences" A fan asks a spoiler question regarding Book in the film that generates much laughter. Ron's response after the laughter dies down "I did have a conversation...well a couple conversations with Joss about that and he assures me that many things are possible" That may not make much sense out of context but if I force it to make sense it'll be a terrible spoiler.
As far as a personal review of this movie goes...without spoiling it...it's certainly not like the TV show. I felt like some things didn't fit as well as they did in the TV format. I believe this to be a TV-to-film translation issue. And also there is the issue of being forced to write a film that non-fans are going to need to become engaged in. Although I still think there are some issues that need to be ironed out. Some non-fans that attended were confused on points regarding who some characters were and why they were important. Also, I didn't like this movies attempt to explain Reavers. That story arc was, I felt, a step backward. Again, no spoliers.
Overall however...the film moves good and engages the viewer well. I give it a thumbs up with some hope that plot points get cleaned up.
thiefjehat | June 30, 07:37 CET