This site will work and look better in a browser that supports web standards, but it is accessible to any browser or Internet device.

Whedonesque - a community weblog about Joss Whedon
"SECOND best."
11944 members | you are not logged in | 25 July 2014












October 22 2005

When is a Loading Dock not a "Loading Dock"? A reader takes Roger Ebert to task in his Answer Man column, for suggesting that Serenity had low-budget look.

From Ebert's Review:

As the battle continued and the heroes were hurled about inside their own spaceship, which at times looked curiously like the interior of a loading dock...


It's a bit of a storm in a tea-cup really, but any further mention of the film on Ebert's site is good.

*rofl* I love Ebert's response.
Yeah he was right to say it looked like a loading dock cause it was suppose to be a loading dock. So I guess they did a pretty good job in making that loading dock set, huh?

I suspect Ebert got a lot of emails(good/bad) just like the San Francisco (something) review.
heh, heh, talk about the nonquestion question. I always love these. Good come back from Ebert.
I once got a five word e-mail from Ebert when I responded to something he wrote. He asked if anyone knew ANYONE who voted for the National Board of Review awards, because he and Gene Siskel (who had passed away a couple of years before this) had never been able to find out anything about the organization -- whose awards are mysteriously seen as harbingers of the Oscars -- beyond a very murky press release or two.

I responded with a not very brief and not-terribly-flattering personal reminiscence about a guy I had known who had bragged about being on the Board, and Ebert's response was: "A picture begins to take shape."

Another time, I guess I submitted a question for the Answer man that he just didn't want to use and I got the slightly more cryptic: "Does not seem to fit."

[ edited by bobster on 2005-10-22 18:17 ]
Well that is kinda funny but it still doesn't negate the girl's point: Ebert had meant the 'loading dock' remark as a bit of a downput, in terms of the sets looking cheap, while the point was that the ship IS cheap and IS a loading dock. That was the whole idea. So in pointing out that that was basically a bit of a dumb complaint to make, she's actually right. Might as well complain about the cheapness of sets making a barnyard look like a barnyard. What else is it supposed to look like?

Hey I don't care, his review was very positive and I couldn't care less about that remark, but the girl who wrote that letter still had a point and that joke he makes basically masks the fact that he's not really answering it.

You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.



joss speaks back home back home back home back home back home